John A Tynan. "Record Review. The Romantic Approach (Capitol)." Down Beat. 28 September 1961. 33.
THE ROMANTIC APPROACH—Capitol 1533; When Your Lover Has Gone; All the Things You Are; I'm Glad There Is You; Say It Isn't So; Imagination; Sweet and Lovely; Fools Rush In; You're Mine, You; Once in a While; Moonlight in Vermont; I Understand; Ohl You Crazy Moon.
Personnel: Ernie Bernhardt, Larry McGuire, Bob Rolfe, Sanford Skinner, Dalton Smith, trumpets; Jim Amlotte, Bob Fitzpatrick, Paul Heydorff, Dave Wheeler, trombones; Dwight Carver, Gordon Davison, Keith Lamotte, Gene Roland, mellophoniums; Gabe Baltazar, Sam Donahue, Wayne Dunstan, Paul Renzi, Marvin Holladay saxophones; Kenton, piano; Clive Acker, tuba; Peter Chivily, bass; Jerry McKenzie, drums.
Rating: (see below)
This is the first recorded sample of the new band and the new Kenton sound, and it is an auspicious debut, to be sure. As a straight, nonjazz ballad set, it rates five stars for the imaginative writing, the richness and depth of velvet brass sounds, and the over-all sensitivity of feeling for the material.
A glance at the titles should be sufficient to impart the mood and tone of the set. It is lush, romantic, and very, very relaxed. Tonally, there are moments approaching musical ecstasy as the mellophoniums rise within the arrangements, bringing to the music an effectively created feeling of rapture. Used in section this is a remarkable instrument for ballads.
While this is hardly an album for hipsters, there is much in the music that stands on merits apart from jazz.
(J.A.T.)